The Mystifying SF Bar Where a President Allegedly Died
Thursday, June 5, 2025
·

"This bar has no clocks, no TVs, and allegedly a presidential ghost nursing a whiskey at the end of the mahogany."
There are some bars that exist outside of time, and then there's the House of Shields.
Tucked into the shadow of the Palace Hotel on New Montgomery Street since 1908, this Victorian relic operates by its own temporal rules. The official story is that President Warren Harding died at the hotel from food poisoning, but others whisper confidently that he died at the House of Shields, with a woman who was not his wife, sneaking out via tunnel. The historical record says one thing. The bartenders will tell you another after your third drink.

Step inside and you're swallowed by dark wood paneling that predates television, the fire, and most of the city's collective memory. No screens flicker with news alerts. No digital clocks tick away the minutes. The only light comes from vintage fixtures that have watched a century of secrets spill across worn leather seats. This isn't just nostalgia, it's a place where time genuinely forgot to keep moving.
The music is modern, sure. DJs spin house tracks between conversations that happen in hushed tones, but somehow the beats feel muffled by history itself. It's as if the bass lines have to push through decades of cigar smoke and whispered scandals to reach your ears. The past isn't preserved here…it's still happening.

The bartenders pour with a heavy hand, and you don't come here for craft cocktails with house-made bitters. You come for the weight of the moment, for the feeling that you've slipped through a crack in San Francisco's timeline and emerged somewhere between Prohibition and yesterday. You come because this is where the city keeps its secrets, where politicians and artists and regular people have been congregating in the dark for over a century.

In a city obsessed with innovation and the future, the House of Shields remains defiantly, gloriously stuck. Here, history doesn't stand still—it breathes.
Authors

Akhil Gutta
